Welcome to the table, we're so happy you're here.

Subscribe to our mailing list and save 15% of your first order.

Free shipping on all orders over $35.

White 20 ounce foam cup with red text checklist reading Naughty, Nice, and a checked I Tried on a plain background.
Red holiday elf doll holding a white 20 ounce foam cup with a red Naughty, Nice, checked I Tried checklist, with green and red felt balls nearby.
White 20 ounce foam cup with red text checklist reading Naughty, Nice, and a checked I Tried on a plain background.
Red holiday elf doll holding a white 20 ounce foam cup with a red Naughty, Nice, checked I Tried checklist, with green and red felt balls nearby.

Gatherings by Curated Paperie

Red Naughty, Nice, I Tried 20oz. Foam Cups

$12.00
$12.00
Sold Out
Sku:

Dear Santa… we tried 😅
These cheeky Christmas party cups are a crowd favorite—perfect for cocoa, cocktails, and every “just one more cookie” moment. Set them out with your naughty or nice decorations and let guests check the only box that truly matters: ✅ I TRIED.

Why you’ll love them

  • Bold red checklist art on both sides—festive from any angle
  • Big 20oz size for hot or cold sips (tailgate to tree-trimming)
  • Lightweight, stackable, and party-proof
  • Perfect For: Cookie swaps • Ugly sweater parties • Office shindigs • Neighbor gifts • Stocking stuffers

Details

  • Set of 10 foam cups (20 oz each), double-sided print
  • Recyclable (#6 polystyrene)
  • CFC & BPA free
    Back to Cowgirl Party Supplies Previous Product Next Product

    Customer Reviews

    Be the first to write a review
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)

    Sign Up

    Stay Set.

    Customer Care

    Company

    © 2025 Moment & Co • Powered by Shopify