Welcome to the table, we're so happy you're here.

My Mind's Eye Christmas

177 products

Light up Christmas village church putz house, white paper with mint green steeple, 10 in
Light Up Christmas Village Church Putz House
Regular Price
$30.00
Sale Price
$30.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Set of 3 green and gold foil paper Christmas village shops, a bakery, toy store, and bookstore, lined up on white
Maren Baxter Limited Edition Lighted Paper Christmas Village Shops, Set of 3
Regular Price
$50.00
Sale Price
$50.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Pink glitter patisserie Christmas house with mint windows, striped awning, wreath, and gray glitter roof, lit on a marble counter
Pink Glitter Patisserie Christmas House
Regular Price
$30.00
Sale Price
$30.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Reindeer shaped paper plate with gold foil antlers, red nose, and red bow
Reindeer Shaped Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Five house-shaped Christmas advent treat boxes grouped together in cream, green, and red village designs
Christmas Village Advent Calendar House Treat Boxes (Set of 25)
Regular Price
$13.00
Sale Price
$13.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Large kraft paper Christmas tree on a retail packaging card
Large Kraft Paper Accordion Christmas Tree (15 inch)
Regular Price
$15.00
Sale Price
$15.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Close-up of the green flocked MERRY CHRISTMAS letters with die-cut metal stars
Merry Christmas Green Flocked Letter Banner with Metal Stars
Regular Price
$20.00
Sale Price
$20.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Merry Christmas gold glitter banner hung on velvet ribbon
Merry Christmas Gold Chipboard Glitter Banner (6 ft)
Regular Price
$15.00
Sale Price
$15.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Brown kraft paper accordion Christmas tree standing open
Kraft Paper Accordion Christmas Tree Decor (11 inch)
Regular Price
$13.00
Sale Price
$13.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Santa canvas advent calendar hung on a white door with a hand reaching for a numbered pocket
Santa Canvas Christmas Advent Calendar Wall Hanging
Regular Price
$20.00
Sale Price
$20.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Cream canvas Christmas advent calendar banner with 24 numbered pockets, wreath design, and red scalloped hem
Christmas Advent Calendar Canvas Banner
Regular Price
$30.00
Sale Price
$30.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Christmas treat boxes open on marble counter with gumballs, lollipops, and gumdrop candies
Vintage Christmas Treat Boxes, Set of 12
Regular Price
$12.00
Sale Price
$12.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Blue glitter Holiday Hotel putz house with silver roof, wreaths, striped awning, and red car with tree
Light Up Christmas Village Holiday Hotel
Regular Price
$35.00
Sale Price
$35.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Green glitter cocoa cafe putz house with snowy roof, red door wreath, and candy striped porch rail
Light Up Christmas Village Cocoa Cafe
Regular Price
$35.00
Sale Price
$35.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Cream scalloped paper plate with red tartan plaid bow and green wavy edge
Plaid Bow Scalloped Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red and green gingham scalloped dinner plates overlapping on a white background.
Red Green Scalloped Gingham Christmas Paper Dinner Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.50
Sale Price
$8.50
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red and pink Santa-shaped paper plate with a cream face design
Red and Pink Santa Shaped Christmas Paper Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Plaid Santa sleigh paper dinner plate with a cream doily, green Santa center, and gold foil edge
Plaid Santa Sleigh Christmas Paper Dinner Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red, green and gold plaid paper table runner shown flat
Red and Green Plaid Christmas Paper Table Runner (16 x 120)
Regular Price
$11.00
Sale Price
$11.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Santa and Christmas tree paper dinner plate with a wavy red edge and holiday icons
Santa and Christmas Tree Wavy Edge Paper Dinner Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red and green plaid Christmas paper fans styled on a wall by a Christmas tree
Red and Green Plaid Christmas Tissue Paper Fans (Set of 5)
Regular Price
$25.00
Sale Price
$25.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

London Christmas jigsaw puzzle design with a red double decker North Pole Express bus, Big Ben, the London Eye and decorated trees in the snow, with Santa and bundled up people walking by
Christmas in London Jigsaw Puzzle (500 Pieces)
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Christmas jigsaw puzzle design made of eight vintage style holiday cards, including a Santa mug, red townhouse, gingerbread man, candy cane, waving Santa, skiing penguin, Christmas tree and dog with mistletoe
Holiday Cheer Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle for Families (500 Pieces)
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Full image of Happy Holidays Ice Skating puzzle.
Happy Holidays Ice Skating Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle (298 Pieces)
Regular Price
$14.00
Sale Price
$14.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Topiary shaped Christmas jigsaw puzzle illustrating the Twelve Days of Christmas, with a partridge, pears, swan, goose, hens, dancers, a milkmaid, drum and gold ring in a red pot with a green bow
Partridge in a Pear Tree Shaped Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle (400 Pieces)
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

City Sidewalks Ice Skating Glitter Jigsaw Puzzle (500 Pieces)
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Storefront shaped Christmas jigsaw puzzle of a red Santa’s Bakery with a pink striped awning, garland, a green door with a wreath and windows full of gingerbread cookies, cakes and bread
Santa's Bakery Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle (503 Pieces)
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Winter jigsaw puzzle design of a red house with a wreath in a snowy evergreen forest, with a woman in a red coat walking a black dog down a snowy path among berry branches
Winter Home Glitter Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle (500 Pieces)
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Finished North Pole Express puzzle artwork of a red train in a snowy village
North Pole Express Train Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle (500 Pieces)
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Finished Christmas sleigh ride puzzle artwork of Santa flying over a snowy village
Sleigh Ride Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle (500 Pieces)
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

It's the most wonderful time of the year, and My Mind's Eye knows how to celebrate!

Discover a merry mix of Christmas party supplies and decorations, from nostalgic Santa illustrations and traditional red and green plaid to vintage Christmas villages, snowy winter scenes, and everything in between. Whether you're hosting Christmas dinner, decorating the house, or planning a holiday party for the little ones, there's plenty to love in our My Mind's Eye Christmas collection.

Find your favorite holiday party supplies, including:

  • Christmas Tableware - Christmas paper plates, dinner napkins, cocktail napkins, cups, serving trays, and table runners for gatherings big and small.
  • Christmas Party Decor - Honeycomb Christmas trees, paper fans, banners, balloons, and felt pennants for decorating throughout the house.
  • Holiday Activities - Christmas jigsaw puzzles, gable treat boxes, and gingerbread aprons for baking cookies, wrapping gifts, and making memories with the family.
  • More Christmas Decorations - Light up putz houses for your Christmas village, vintage inspired wall decor, and adorable Advent calendars to count down the days.

From Christmas Eve traditions to the excitement of Christmas morning, there's something for every celebration. So pour the hot cocoa, put on your favorite Christmas carols, and make this holiday season one to remember!