Welcome to the table, we're so happy you're here.

My Mind's Eye Christmas

177 products

Cream round paper plate with a bold red zig-zag edge on a white background.
Red Zig Zag Cream Christmas Paper Dinner Plates
Regular Price
$8.50
Sale Price
$8.50
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Die-cut Santa face paper plate in cream, red, and peach with gold-foil accents on a white background.
Christmas Santa Face Shaped Paper Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

5 cream house-shaped Christmas advent boxes with red, green, peach, and taupe roofs and wreaths in the windows
Christmas House Advent Calendar Boxes
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red square paper plate with a cream woodland folk art design of deer, cardinals, squirrels, and pinecones and a cream scalloped edge
Red Woodland Square Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red house-shaped Christmas paper dinner plate with green and cream accents
Red House Shaped Christmas Paper Dinner Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Square cream paper plate with a green toile print of Santa's sleigh, reindeer, snowmen, and fir trees and a green wavy scalloped edge
Green Toile Santa Square Christmas Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Happy Holidays village paper salad plate with a Christmas icon illustration and gold foil
Happy Holidays Village Christmas Paper Salad Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red and green plaid paper dinner plate with a dotted scalloped edge
Red and Green Plaid Scalloped Paper Dinner Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.50
Sale Price
$8.50
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Green square Happy Holidays paper dinner plate with a cream and pink illustration
Green Happy Holidays Square Paper Dinner Plates (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Cream paper plate with a green Christmas tree, gingham bow, and red Merry Christmas script inside a wavy red scalloped edge
Merry Christmas Tree Scalloped Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Multicolor gingham square paper plate with a gold foil wavy line
Multicolor Gingham Square Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red and green tartan plaid square paper plate with green scalloped edge
Red Plaid Square Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.50
Sale Price
$8.50
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Unrolled green and cream floral stripe paper table runner on a white background
Green Floral Stripe Paper Table Runner
Regular Price
$11.00
Sale Price
$11.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Green die-cut Christmas wreath plate with red and cream dot accents and a gingham bow on a white background.
Christmas Wreath Shaped Paper Plates Green (Set of 8)
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Mint paper house with windows and door glowing from the interior light on a white background
Mint Christmas Village Paper Putz House with Light
Regular Price
$30.00
Sale Price
$30.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Close-up of ‘Merry’ and ‘Santa’ felt pennants surrounded by plates, cookies, and gifts.
Christmas Merry & Santa Felt Pennants (Set of 2)
Regular Price
$18.00
Sale Price
$18.00
Regular Price
$18.00
Unit Price
per 

Layered cake topped with Believe and North Pole felt pennant flags, styled with red and white Christmas party supplies.
Christmas Believe North Pole Felt Pennant Set
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Styled scene with Naughty and Nice felt Christmas pennant banners, ornaments, and ribbon—tabletop flatlay.
Christmas Naughty Nice Felt Pennant Banners
Regular Price
$15.00
Sale Price
$15.00
Regular Price
$15.00
Unit Price
per 

Isolated view of a single bow plate showing the red ribbon design and scalloped edge plates detail.
Christmas Red Bow Border Paper Plates
Regular Price
$7.00
Sale Price
$7.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Isolated view of a single winking Santa plate die-cut paper plate shape with a red hat.
Christmas Santa Shaped Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Isolated view of a single pink Christmas plate showing the candy cane and holly repeat pattern.
Christmas Candy Cane Patterned Plates
Regular Price
$7.00
Sale Price
$7.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Plaid party cup with green scalloped rim and red paper bow
Plaid Paper Cups with Bows, Set of 8: Red Gingham Christmas Party Cups for Hot Cocoa or Holiday Drinks
Regular Price
$10.00
Sale Price
$10.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Red bow banner with eight paper bows hanging on cream ribbon
Red Bow Christmas Paper Banner
Regular Price
$16.00
Sale Price
$16.00
Regular Price
$16.00
Unit Price
per 

Isolated view of a single ornament shaped napkin in red, pink, and green die-cut design.
Christmas Ornament Cocktail Paper Napkins
Regular Price
$7.00
Sale Price
$7.00
Regular Price
$7.00
Unit Price
per 

Isolated set of four assembled Christmas poppers showing the red and pink gingham pattern and character cutouts.
Red Plaid Christmas Poppers
Regular Price
$21.00
Sale Price
$21.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Isolated view of a single red gingham paper plate showing the red and pink plaid pattern and green scalloped edge.
Christmas Red Plaid Scalloped Edge Plate
Regular Price
$8.50
Sale Price
$8.50
Regular Price
$8.50
Unit Price
per 

Isolated view of the red plaid napkins showing the gingham pattern and green scalloped bottom trim.
Christmas Red Plaid Napkins with Bow Paper Rings
Regular Price
$9.00
Sale Price
$9.00
Regular Price
$9.00
Unit Price
per 

Red and white gingham cookie box with scalloped window and red bow
Red Gingham Christmas Cookie Boxes
Regular Price
$13.00
Sale Price
$13.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Isolated image of a single square Red Star Plate showing the red and white pattern and scalloped edge.
Christmas Large Red Star Square Paper Plates
Regular Price
$8.00
Sale Price
$8.00
Regular Price
$8.00
Unit Price
per 

Product on white—5 ft felt Merry Christmas banner with candy-cane ribbon tails.
Thick Felt Merry Christmas Banner
Regular Price
$24.00
Sale Price
$24.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

It's the most wonderful time of the year, and My Mind's Eye knows how to celebrate!

Discover a merry mix of Christmas party supplies and decorations, from nostalgic Santa illustrations and traditional red and green plaid to vintage Christmas villages, snowy winter scenes, and everything in between. Whether you're hosting Christmas dinner, decorating the house, or planning a holiday party for the little ones, there's plenty to love in our My Mind's Eye Christmas collection.

Find your favorite holiday party supplies, including:

  • Christmas Tableware - Christmas paper plates, dinner napkins, cocktail napkins, cups, serving trays, and table runners for gatherings big and small.
  • Christmas Party Decor - Honeycomb Christmas trees, paper fans, banners, balloons, and felt pennants for decorating throughout the house.
  • Holiday Activities - Christmas jigsaw puzzles, gable treat boxes, and gingerbread aprons for baking cookies, wrapping gifts, and making memories with the family.
  • More Christmas Decorations - Light up putz houses for your Christmas village, vintage inspired wall decor, and adorable Advent calendars to count down the days.

From Christmas Eve traditions to the excitement of Christmas morning, there's something for every celebration. So pour the hot cocoa, put on your favorite Christmas carols, and make this holiday season one to remember!